zrdb what makes you say that? MediaInfo shows it’s straight out of MakeMKV.
Without a BDMV/ISO of the bonus disc (can only find dead DDL links) it’s safe to assume they did actually put the video on there twice, the audio tracks on both have the same source ID which I don’t think is possible within the same m2ts file, 4352 (0x1100).
-46h looks similar, no point in posting long MediaInfo twice.
The video streams aren’t identical - you can demux them and try and hash them if you want. I doubt anyone would be able to tell the difference, since there’s a sizable chunk of the video where the SSIM score is 1.00 and I didn’t see it dip below 0.989 - admittedly useless since you can assign either as the “source” - point being, nearly identical, but still different video. Same source, different audio track, slightly lower maximum bitrate allotted to the video with 5.1 audio because there are less bits available now and we have to stay under 40MbpsTechnically the video track included with the Stereo audio might be higher quality, if >size automatically = >quality with whatever encoder they used when they authored the disc - but again, even pixel peeping wherever it scored lowest, I’d be arsed if I could tell either from the other. Even x264’s output is non-deterministic by default.
Comments - 5
uberasian
I know that (-46) is the new special… what is the (-120) special?
ElderKai (uploader)
@uberasian
(-120min) is EVA-EXTRA-EXTRA Manga.
rocknard
You could remux the audios and avoid x2 waste space? 200-300MB is nothing.
Thanks, i was looking for this.
PS: x264 or x265? my pc is slow. English subs?
zrdb
This is not a re-mux-it’s a “re-encode”.
bood
zrdb what makes you say that? MediaInfo shows it’s straight out of MakeMKV.
Without a BDMV/ISO of the bonus disc (can only find dead DDL links) it’s safe to assume they did actually put the video on there twice, the audio tracks on both have the same source ID which I don’t think is possible within the same m2ts file,
4352 (0x1100)
.Evangelion 3.0 (-120min) You Can (Not) Redo. (2.0).mkv
https://files.catbox.moe/kl0rdy.txt
Evangelion 3.0 (-120min) You Can (Not) Redo. (5.1).mkv
https://files.catbox.moe/ixdx02.txt
-46h looks similar, no point in posting long MediaInfo twice.
The video streams aren’t identical - you can demux them and try and hash them if you want. I doubt anyone would be able to tell the difference, since there’s a sizable chunk of the video where the SSIM score is 1.00 and I didn’t see it dip below 0.989 - admittedly useless since you can assign either as the “source” - point being, nearly identical, but still different video. Same source, different audio track, slightly lower maximum bitrate allotted to the video with 5.1 audio because
there are less bits available now and we have to stay under 40Mbps
Technically the video track included with the Stereo audio might be higher quality, if>size
automatically =>quality
with whatever encoder they used when they authored the disc - but again, even pixel peeping wherever it scored lowest, I’d be arsed if I could tell either from the other. Even x264’s output is non-deterministic by default.